Sports podiatrist Simon Bartold holding a running shoe in front of a footwear displaySimon Bartold. Image: Simon Bartold / LinkedIn

Foot orthoses should be judged by how they change load and how the patient responds, not by whether they make a foot look straighter. That is the message from Australian sports podiatrist Simon Bartold, founder of Bartold Clinical, in a widely shared LinkedIn post this week.

Bartold, who has spent decades working on running footwear research and development and hosts the SHOEphoria podcast, argues that the profession has moved on from simple alignment-based explanations of how orthoses work.

Pronation is not a pathology

“Foot posture is not a diagnosis,” Bartold writes. In his view, pronation is not harmful in itself, and an orthosis does not need to change skeletal alignment to help a patient. What orthoses can do is shift plantar pressure, alter the external moments acting on joints and change how tissues are loaded. How much they do so depends on the device, the shoe it sits in, the activity and the person wearing it.

What it means for prefabricated orthoses

Bartold says this matters most when clinicians choose prefabricated devices. A custom-made orthosis is not always needed to produce a useful mechanical change. Instead, he sets out three things a prescription needs:

  • a clear clinical objective
  • an intervention suited to that objective
  • a way to measure how the patient responds

The aim, he says, is not a foot that looks right but a patient who can move more comfortably and cope with the loads that matter in their daily life or sport. He closes by asking clinicians how much weight they still give to static foot posture when they prescribe.

IMEA POD Perspective

This debate has practical consequences across the IMEA region. In many clinics, a custom orthosis is expensive, takes weeks to fabricate and may need the patient to travel back for fitting. If the clinical goal can often be reached with a well-chosen prefabricated device, more patients can be treated sooner and at lower cost, freeing custom work for the feet that genuinely need it.

Footwear is part of the same equation. Orthoses only work inside a suitable shoe, and in hot climates where sandals, slippers and barefoot walking are common, that cannot be assumed. Bartold’s framework also leaves room for caution: the high-risk diabetic foot, where offloading and pressure redistribution are the clinical objective, still calls for careful device selection and close follow-up rather than an off-the-shelf default. Whichever device is chosen, recording a clear objective and reviewing the patient’s response is good practice that any foot team can adopt.

How much weight do you give static foot posture when you prescribe orthoses? Tell us on LinkedIn.

Sources and further reading

Leave a Reply